UK Flag
USA Flag

How to Appeal an HMRC Penalty in 2026: Step-by-Step Guide for Self Assessment Tax Returns

How to Appeal an HMRC Penalty in 2026: Step-by-Step Guide for Self Assessment Tax Returns
Table of Contents

You can appeal an HMRC penalty if you have a reasonable excuse for missing a Self Assessment deadline or believe the penalty is wrong. You normally have 30 days from the date on the penalty notice to appeal online, using form SA370, or by letter. Include your evidence and file any outstanding return.

Receiving a penalty letter from HMRC can be frustrating, especially when you are already dealing with bills, tax returns and other financial responsibilities. A £100 late filing penalty may seem manageable at first, but further charges can quickly increase the amount you owe. If you are a sole trader, landlord, individual taxpayer or owner of a small business, an unexpected tax penalty can put additional pressure on your finances.

The good news is that you do not always have to accept a penalty. You can explain what happened, provide evidence and ask HMRC to reconsider the penalty. The appeal process covers late filing and late payment penalties, and you can also appeal Making Tax Digital penalty points and £200 penalties, but your circumstances must support your appeal.

In this guide, we explain how to appeal an HMRC penalty in 2026, which reasons HMRC may accept, the deadlines you need to follow, and what happens after you submit an appeal.

Can You Appeal an HMRC Penalty for Self Assessment?

Self Assessment is HMRC’s system for collecting Income Tax from people whose tax is not fully deducted through PAYE. It usually applies to sole traders, landlords, people with additional income and other taxpayers who need to report their income through a tax return.

HMRC may issue a penalty if you submit your tax return late or fail to pay your tax by the due date. You can appeal an HMRC penalty if you think it is incorrect or you had a reasonable excuse for missing the deadline. For example, a serious illness, unexpected hospital admission or bereavement may have prevented you from meeting your tax obligations. You can also ask HMRC to cancel a penalty if you were charged for not sending a return that you did not need to send.

You can appeal against a Self Assessment penalty even if you have already filed your return late. You must explain why you missed the deadline, when the problem occurred and how quickly you acted once the situation improved. HMRC considers appeals individually, so having a reason does not automatically guarantee that the penalty will be cancelled. If there is no reasonable excuse, HMRC has limited discretion to reduce a penalty because of special circumstances.

How to Appeal an HMRC Penalty: Step by Step

If you believe your penalty is unfair or incorrect, follow these steps to appeal an HMRC penalty.

Step 1: Check your penalty notice

Check the amount charged, the tax year, the reason for the penalty and the date of issue. Note the issue date, because your appeal deadline runs from the date printed on the notice, not the date you received it.

Step 2: Submit your tax return

If your return is outstanding, file it as soon as possible. An appeal does not remove your filing obligation.

Step 3: Check your reason for appealing

Make sure you have a valid reason, such as a reasonable excuse or an HMRC error, that you can explain clearly. You may also appeal if you did not need to file a return.

Step 4: Collect evidence

Gather documents that support your explanation, such as medical records, screenshots of technical problems or relevant letters.

Step 5: Submit your appeal

Use HMRC’s online appeal service or the appropriate postal form. Explain what happened and include the relevant dates. Tell HMRC the date the penalty was issued, the date you filed your return and the details of your reasonable excuse. If you are appealing late, explain why.

Step 6: Keep a record

Save your appeal, supporting documents and confirmation that you submitted it.

Step 7: Wait for HMRC’s decision

HMRC will review your case and decide whether to cancel or uphold the penalty. If your appeal is rejected, you may have further options.

Acting promptly and giving HMRC a clear explanation can make the process easier to manage.

Do you have to pay the penalty while you appeal?

In law, you do not have to pay a penalty before your appeal is decided, and HMRC’s guidance is that the penalty is normally held while it considers your appeal. Interest may be charged if your appeal is unsuccessful and you pay after the deadline.

Self Assessment Penalty Amounts for 2025/26

HMRC charges penalties for late tax returns and late payments. The amount depends on how long you have delayed filing or paying.

PenaltyAmount
Late filing£100 immediately
Return more than 3 months late£10 daily for up to 90 days, maximum £900
Return more than 6 months late5% of tax due or £300, whichever is higher
Return more than 12 months lateAdditional 5% of tax due or £300, whichever is higher
Tax payment 30 days late5% of unpaid tax
Tax payment 6 months lateAdditional 5% of unpaid tax
Tax payment 12 months lateAdditional 5% of unpaid tax

Late payment interest may also be charged. HMRC’s rate is 4 percentage points above the Bank of England base rate and rises to 8.00% from 24 November 2026. This interest is separate from any penalties and from the tax you owe, so filing your return and paying as soon as possible limits the extra cost. The existing penalty rules continue for 2025/26 and 2026/27 for taxpayers not yet in Making Tax Digital for Income Tax.

What Is the Deadline to Appeal an HMRC Penalty for Self Assessment?

You should normally appeal within 30 days of the date shown on the penalty notice, not the date you receive it. HMRC’s internal guidance allows a further seven days for printing and posting the notice, but you should treat 30 days as your deadline.

Important Self Assessment deadlines

Tax requirementDeadline
Paper tax return31 October 2026 (passed)
Online tax return31 January 2027
Tax payment31 January 2027
Penalty appealNormally within 30 days of the date on the penalty notice.

For the 2025/26 tax year, the paper filing deadline was 31 October 2026. The online filing and payment deadline is 31 January 2027.

If you miss the 30-day appeal deadline, you may still be able to appeal, but you must explain why your appeal is late. Do not delay if you believe HMRC has made a mistake.

How to Appeal an HMRC Penalty After the 30 Day Deadline

If you miss the 30 day appeal deadline, you may still be able to appeal, but you must explain why your appeal is late. Explain clearly why you could not appeal sooner, for example because of illness or a hospital stay, and send your appeal as soon as you can. HMRC decides whether to accept a late appeal. Do not delay if you believe HMRC has made a mistake.

What Counts as a Reasonable Excuse for HMRC?

HMRC considers whether something outside your control prevented you from filing your return or paying on time. You must also take action as soon as you are able to resolve the issue. Once the problem has ended, you need to file or pay without unreasonable delay.

What may count as a reasonable excuseWhat usually does not count
Serious illness or unexpected hospital stayNot having enough money to pay tax, unless it was caused by events outside your control
Death of a close family member shortly before the deadlineForgetting the deadline
Fire, flood or theft affecting your recordsBeing too busy with work
HMRC online service problemsFinding the HMRC website difficult to use
Computer or software failure while filingNot receiving a reminder
Unexpected postal delaysMaking a mistake on your return
Disability or mental health difficulties affecting your ability to manage tax affairsIgnoring HMRC letters

HMRC looks at the facts of each case. You should explain how the situation stopped you from meeting the deadline and show that you filed or paid as soon as you reasonably could. Supporting evidence can make your explanation easier to assess. A shortage of money is not a reasonable excuse on its own, but the underlying cause may be if you acted promptly to put things right.

How to Appeal an HMRC Penalty Online or by Post (SA370, SA371 and Letter)

You can appeal a penalty online or by post. The right method depends on your circumstances and whether you prefer completing an online form or sending a written explanation.

Online appealAppeal by post
Use HMRC’s online appeal serviceUse the relevant postal appeal form
Submit your explanation electronicallyWrite your explanation and attach evidence
Convenient and generally quicker to submitUseful if you prefer paper records
Follow the online instructionsComplete, sign and date your form
Keep your online confirmationKeep copies and proof of postage
Suitable for penalties on individual Self Assessment returnsSA370 for individuals and SA371 for partnerships, as applicable

For a partnership return, use form SA371. Only the nominated partner can appeal a penalty on a partnership return.

You can also appeal by letter. Send it to Self Assessment, HM Revenue and Customs, BX9 1AS, United Kingdom. Include the date the penalty was issued, the date you filed your return and the details of your reasonable excuse.

Choose the method that lets you keep a clear record of your appeal. If you prefer to appeal by post, check the HMRC instructions for the correct form and postal address before sending it.

What Evidence Should You Include in Your Appeal?

Evidence helps HMRC understand why you missed the deadline and whether you had a reasonable excuse. Instead of simply saying you could not file on time, explain what happened and include relevant supporting documents.

Depending on your circumstances, include:

  • Medical evidence: Medical letters, hospital records or certificates.
  • Bereavement details: Relevant dates and supporting documents.
  • Technical evidence: Screenshots of error messages or HMRC service problems.
  • Computer records: Evidence of software failure or system issues.
  • Emergency records: Documents relating to fire, flood or theft.
  • Timeline: Dates showing when the problem began and when you resolved it.

Only include evidence that supports your appeal. Keep your explanation factual and make sure the dates are correct.

What Happens After You Appeal?

Once you submit your appeal, HMRC will look at the reason you are challenging the penalty and any evidence you have provided. The officer handling your case will reconsider the penalty and may contact you if they need further information, such as documents, dates or clarification about your circumstances. You should respond promptly to avoid unnecessary delays.

If your appeal is accepted: HMRC may cancel the penalty. If you have already paid it, HMRC will arrange a repayment, subject to any outstanding tax you owe.

If HMRC asks for more information: You may need to provide additional documents or explain your situation in more detail. Respond within the time HMRC gives you.

If your appeal is rejected: HMRC will explain why it has not agreed to cancel the penalty. You can still challenge the decision through the next stage of the appeal process. You usually have 30 days from the date of the decision letter to accept a review or appeal to the tax tribunal.

Request an independent review: You can ask a different HMRC officer, who was not involved in the original decision, to review your case. This is usually completed within 45 days.

Take your case to a tribunal: If you disagree with the review outcome, you may be able to appeal to the First tier Tribunal (Tax), an independent body that considers arguments from both sides and makes a decision. You must usually do this within 30 days of the date on the review result letter.

If you have not heard back, check your online Self Assessment account and any post from HMRC, then contact HMRC and quote the date on your penalty notice.

Keep copies of your appeal, evidence and all HMRC correspondence until the matter is resolved. Submitting an appeal does not mean your penalty has automatically been cancelled, so make sure you understand the outcome and any further action required.

Can You Appeal if You’ve Already Paid the Penalty?

Yes, you can appeal a Self Assessment penalty even if you have already paid it. Payment does not mean you have given up your right to challenge the penalty.

If HMRC accepts your appeal, it will repay the cancelled penalty. HMRC may also pay interest on the repayment, subject to the applicable rules and any outstanding tax you owe.

Include the payment details in your appeal and explain why you believe the penalty should be cancelled. If you have not paid, HMRC’s guidance is that the penalty is normally held while your appeal is considered, but interest may apply if your appeal is unsuccessful and you pay late.

Can’t Afford the Penalty and Tax Bill? Your Options

If you cannot afford your tax bill and penalty, do not ignore HMRC. You may have options to manage your payments and deal with your tax obligations.

Time to Pay arrangement: Ask HMRC whether you can spread your tax bill over monthly instalments. If you owe less than £30,000 and are within 60 days of the payment deadline, you may be able to set one up online, provided you have filed all your returns and have no other HMRC debts.

Pay what you can: Paying towards the balance may help reduce what remains outstanding.

Appeal the penalty: If you have a reasonable excuse, you can challenge the penalty separately.

Review your budget: Work out what you can realistically afford to pay.

Get professional help: An accountant can help you understand your options and communicate with HMRC.

Contact HMRC as early as possible if you are struggling to pay. Leaving it until further charges are added may make your situation harder to manage.

Should You Use an Accountant to Appeal?

Yes, an accountant can help you understand your penalty, prepare your appeal and avoid unnecessary mistakes. This can be particularly useful if you have multiple penalties or are unsure whether your circumstances qualify as a reasonable excuse.

An accountant can help you:

  • Check whether the penalty has been calculated correctly.
  • Explain your reason for appealing clearly.
  • Identify evidence that may support your case.
  • Deal with HMRC correspondence.
  • Explore payment arrangements for outstanding tax.
  • Keep your tax returns and records in order.

Getting professional advice can save time and help you approach HMRC with greater confidence.

Common Mistakes That Get an HMRC Penalty Appeal Rejected

When you appeal a Self Assessment penalty, it is important to provide the right information and follow HMRC’s process. Avoid these common mistakes.

1. Giving a vague explanation

Saying you were busy or forgot the deadline may not be enough. Explain what happened, how it affected you and why you could not meet the deadline.

2. Missing the appeal deadline

Submit your appeal within 30 days wherever possible. If you are late, explain why you could not appeal sooner.

3. Leaving your tax return outstanding

Appealing a penalty does not replace your duty to file. Submit your tax return as soon as possible to avoid further late filing charges.

4. Providing no evidence

Include relevant documents that support your explanation. Evidence may help HMRC understand your circumstances.

5. Ignoring HMRC correspondence

Respond to requests for information and keep records of all communication. Ignoring letters may delay your appeal or make it harder to resolve.

If you are unsure how to appeal an HMRC penalty correctly, MyIVA can help you review your tax position, organise your paperwork and avoid these mistakes.

FAQs: Frequently Asked Questions

How long do I have to appeal an HMRC penalty for Self Assessment?

You usually have 30 days from the date of the penalty notice. If you miss the deadline, explain why and ask HMRC to accept your late appeal.

How long does HMRC take to decide?

It depends on your case and whether HMRC needs more information. HMRC will write to tell you its decision. If you have not heard back, check your online account and post, then contact HMRC and quote the date on your penalty notice.

What happens if my appeal is rejected?

You may request a review or take your case to the tax tribunal, depending on your circumstances. Follow the options and deadlines in HMRC’s decision letter, which usually allow 30 days.

Can I appeal a late payment penalty?

Yes, if you have a reasonable excuse or believe the penalty is wrong. Explain why you could not pay on time and provide supporting evidence.

Do I still pay interest while I appeal?

Interest may continue on unpaid tax while your appeal is considered. An appeal does not automatically stop late payment interest.

Can I appeal an HMRC penalty if it is my first offence?

Yes, you can appeal, but there is no automatic cancellation for a first offence. HMRC considers the reason you missed the deadline and the circumstances of your case.

Is it worth paying someone to appeal a £100 penalty?

You may be able to appeal a straightforward penalty yourself for free. Professional help may be useful if the case is complicated or involves several penalties.

Can I appeal if I did not need to file a tax return?

Yes. If you were charged a penalty for not sending a tax return that you did not need to send, ask HMRC to cancel it.

Do I have to pay the penalty while I appeal?

In law you do not have to pay a penalty before your appeal is decided, and HMRC normally holds it while it considers your appeal. Interest may apply if the appeal fails and you pay late.

Conclusion

Receiving a Self Assessment penalty does not always mean you have to accept it. If you believe HMRC has made an error or you had a reasonable excuse for missing a deadline, you can appeal an HMRC penalty and explain your circumstances. Acting promptly, providing evidence and meeting the appeal deadline can help you avoid further problems.

If you are struggling with a penalty, an unpaid tax bill or your Self Assessment return, getting the right help can make a difference. Keeping your records organised and dealing with HMRC early can help you stay on top of your finances.

Need Help to Appeal an HMRC Penalty? MyIVA helps individuals, sole traders and small business owners review their penalty notice, gather evidence and deal with HMRC. Speak to our team and get your Self Assessment back on track.

Pooja

Pooja Sail

Associate Director at MyIVA

Pooja Sail is an Associate Director at MyIVA and a qualified Chartered Accountant from the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI), with over 15 years of experience in UK accounting, taxation, and financial management.

Her professional foundation was built during a 3.5-year articleship at R. P. Sangodkar & Co., a Mumbai-based chartered accountancy firm, where she developed deep expertise in finance and compliance. She went on to earn her Chartered Accountancy qualification from ICAI between 2006 and 2016, alongside a Bachelor’s degree in Commerce with distinction from Vaze College, Mumbai.

Over the course of her career, Pooja has held leadership roles managing finance and accounting teams, most notably as Manager at Corient Business Solutions Limited for over 8 years before transitioning to her current role as Associate Director at MyIVA. At MyIVA, she serves as an end-to-end resource for small businesses, overseeing everything from taxation and compliance to the broader financial operations that keep businesses running smoothly, making her a trusted and reliable partner for small business owners navigating complex financial landscapes.

Share On:

Contact Us

Related Blogs

How to Pay Self Assessment Tax Online or by Bank Transfer

How to Pay Self Assessment Tax Online or by Bank Transfer

Here is how to pay Self Assessment: use your bank app, the HMRC app or a debit card, send a Faster Payments or Bacs bank

https://www.gov.uk/self-assessment-tax-returns

Self Assessment for Directors 2025/26: Who Must File & Deadlines

Do company directors have to file a Self Assessment tax return? Not automatically. A UK director taxed only on a PAYE salary may not need

Missed Self Assessment Registration Deadline? What to Do Now (2026)

Missed Self Assessment Registration Deadline? What to Do Now (2026)

If you’ve missed the Self Assessment registration deadline, register with HMRC straight away. HMRC doesn’t charge an automatic fine for registering late. A failure to